The golden temple is fascinating enough to make Amritsar a must-see. The Wagah border, about 7 miles away from Amristar, is captivating, slightly scary, and not a little funny. The Wagah border is currently the only way to cross the border between India and Pakistan over land. Each and every night the Indian and Pakistani border authorities hold joint/rival closing ceremony(ies) that takes place in front of thousands of spectators. On our way, we drove past lines of trucks carrying goods for Pakistan that hadn't made it in time to cross over. Park about a kilometer from the entrance and walk through a gangway filled with Indian propaganda and advertisements for fans. We saw a man wearing a trojan hat. My dad pointed at the novelty and our tour guide laughed, because we'd be seeing a lot more trojan hats throughout the evening.
After we past through border through border security we were seated in pretty prime location. The Indian arena was already pretty full. By pretty full I mean there were over a thousand people there. The Pakistani side was completely empty, but I could already see that it was nicer. For one thing we had some of the best seats but when we sat straight ahead the thing that was easiest to see was the Indian people sitting on the other side of the path. Looking at the pristine marble that was used for the Pakistani stadium, I'm pretty sure that people sitting there would not have been covered in dust after the experience like we were. Back on the Indian side, People, mostly women and children took turns running with the flag up and down the route to the gates at the border, while bollywood music played. After half an hour of this the Pakistani spectactors started to file in. Their stadium wasn't full, but it was larger so I would hazard to guess that there were about thousand spectators on each side.
Then the ceremony started. A man who I can only describe as a cheerleader on the Indian side started screaming "oooooooooooooh," in one breath while his couterpart started at the same time and tried to outlast him. The pakistani cheer leader always lasted longer, but the Indian would always start again when he realised he'd been bested to make it seem like he had won Meanwhile men on both sides with feathered helmets with different colors goose stepped up and down the path to cheers of "Hindustan."
Words and even pictures cannot do it justice, so luckily I have video or found one on youtube.
Neither my father nor I saw the hand shake. I wonder how many other spectators miss that.
As my father has become fond of saying: "It's HILARIOUS, until you realize both of these countries have nuclear weapons. I'm not sure it's really any different from the Olympics or the World Cup, but then I'm ambivalent about the constructiveness of those events as well. Sports is a zero sum game: when the Dutch are happy, the Brazilians are sad. Is that really an attitude you want to foster on a daily basis. Well, some people do want to foster that attitude. That, in a nutshell, is my problem. In the end, while the ceremonies may not be so different from events that are important in my life, that doesn't mean they aren't harming the process of coexistence.
The thing I was the most uncomfortable with was the use of the word "Hinndustan."Hindustan is my least favorite name for India since it means land of the Hindus. As the above picture shows, it is not only Hindus invested in the fate of India. India is a secular country with more Muslims citizens than Pakistan. There are those within the Indian political establishment who would have India be in the exclusive control of the Hindus, and they have dangerous ideas about the future of the country. I much prefer India or "Bharat" the historical name for the region. Although I guess Pakistan is/was also part of Bharat and thus would be a little awkward. Like red sox shouting "North America" in the faces of Yankees fans.
Still an open land border between the two countries has to ultimately allow for further exposure to each other, and I'm a big believer that more exposure to those from other places leads to better understanding. At the same time if this exposure comes through a prism of screams and skilled marches, is it really exposure at all?
On a side note, on the way back we ran into a boy hawking DVDs wearing. A daisy girl scout shirt. Maybe this is only interesting to other girl scouts, but the whole thing seemed reminiscent of Jacqueline Novogratz's The Blue Sweater and had to take a picture.
